Memorial booklet for Benjamin Barragan
Half one among a sequence
A Native American man thrusts lean arms to the heavens, beseeching Father Sky for blessings, for steering, for peace.
That’s the quilt of Benjamin Barragan’s memorial program. There’s Barragan, grinning extensively in snapshots together with his 5 kids, posing together with his elders, clutching a basketball.
Barragan, 29, was a member of the Spirit Lake tribe in North Dakota. In Might, he was recruited to an habit therapy program in sunny Southern California. In June, he was useless. “Place of Death: Sober Living Facility,” the coroner’s information say.
Web page from Benjamin Barragan’s memorial program (Courtesy Barragan household)
Hopes for a brand new life led to early dying for Margaret Dickerson as nicely. From Illinois, she had struggled with habit for years, based on her post-mortem report. She got here to California for therapy simply three weeks earlier than a cocaine, fentanyl and methamphetamine cocktail killed her on Jan. 29 in North Hollywood. Fellow sufferers mentioned she by no means fairly made it into therapy: After she obtained right here, “insurance discrepancies” cropped up and he or she was “unable to attend be housed (sic) at the facility and subsequently became homeless,” the post-mortem says. She was 41.
Emmanuel Mitchell got here from Oklahoma, packing a historical past of cocaine and Percocet abuse. After spending time in detox — the costliest degree of state-licensed habit therapy in California — he spent two weeks in a sober dwelling house in Los Angeles. He and different residents would typically come and go together with no supervision, his post-mortem notes. He was final seen alive going into a rest room at about 6:15 p.m. on Feb. 7. Minutes later, he was discovered unresponsive on the ground. He overdosed on fentanyl, the post-mortem concluded. He was 28.
What these folks had in frequent — in addition to visions of a contemporary begin removed from house — was that they landed within the huge rehab empire overseen by Nathan Younger, aka “Pablo Lopez,” and associates.
Younger’s community weaponizes habit for revenue, insurance coverage large Aetna has charged in a $40 million lawsuit. One among his sober dwelling houses was denounced as a “haven for drug abuse” and sued by authorities. A lot of Younger’s operations maintain their state licenses and certifications at the same time as state regulators attempt to revoke others, calling some amenities “harmful to client health and safety.”
“SCAM ALERT!” a warning from the state of Delaware screamed on June 7. “The claims of residential treatment services and ongoing treatment in California are likely FALSE CLAIMS. Beware of body brokering, cash offers, kickbacks, and insurance fraud.”
Delaware singled out Santa Monica Rehab — one among Younger’s many companies — within the Rip-off Alert. Simply days later — on June 13 — Barragan died.
“It’s so jumbled,” mentioned a distraught Xavier Barragan shortly after his brother’s dying. “It was a bunch of lies.”
Younger’s defenders say that, most sadly, habit is a situation that may finish in dying.
‘Harmful to client health’
On Oct. 10, many months after we started reporting this story and a few years after complaints from former employees and sufferers started rolling in, the California Division of Well being Care Providers (DHCS) served an accusation, discover of license revocation, and fast momentary suspension order to Elmo Detox in Los Angeles and Rodeo Restoration in Beverly Hills, two of Younger’s many operations.
DHCS took related motion in opposition to Younger’s thirty third Avenue Detox in Might. Younger is combating Elmo’s closure in courtroom, however because the state licenses every therapy facility individually, some 30 residential and outpatient facilities in Younger’s community stay open, based on DHCS information.
The licensed rehabs embrace Santa Monica Detox in Santa Monica, Joser Without end in Los Angeles, Revive Premier Remedy Middle in Studio Metropolis, Therapeutic Path Detox in Huntington Seashore, Ocean Valley Behavioral Well being in Santa Ana, Sundown Rehab in West Hollywood, Pure Relaxation Home in La Quinta, Antioch Rehab in Los Angeles and the Kiloby Middle for Restoration in Rancho Mirage, based on DHCS and courtroom paperwork.
There’s additionally a sprawling community of sober dwelling houses which have operated underneath the 9 Silver and 55 Silver manufacturers, stretching from Ventura to Los Angeles to Orange and Riverside counties. Many consumers enrolled in outpatient therapy stay in these houses, that are marijuana-friendly. Sober houses don’t want licenses, as no therapy is meant to occur there, and the federal government can’t deal with them otherwise than every other household.
Overdoses have occurred in licensed and unlicensed houses alike, based on paperwork from DHCS and the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner.
• False record-keeping. Detox is essentially the most fraught stage of therapy, and could be lethal. Elmo staffers did not examine on sufferers going by way of withdrawal at required intervals after which falsified information to say they did, the state mentioned.
• Overdose. A affected person left in opposition to medical recommendation shortly earlier than New 12 months’s, returned the subsequent day with fentanyl hidden in a hair scrunchie, then overdosed on website. The affected person needed to be revived with 5 sprays of Narcan. Although coverage requires fast discharge and referral to different packages for on-site overdoses, the shopper was allowed to stay on website. “I left because I’ve been asking these (expletives) … to take me to the hospital,” the DHCS quotes the affected person as saying. “None of the staff would take me to a doctor. I could not breathe, I kept coughing, and I have bronchitis. I asked every single staff member … to take me to the doctor, but they were all too busy….” The affected person’s insurance coverage was approved for habit therapy by way of Jan. 11, they usually have been discharged that day.
• Unreported psychological well being breakdown requiring emergency care. After relapsing and utilizing medicine a number of instances final December, a shopper grew to become hysterical throughout a bunch remedy session, punching themselves and banging their head on the ground. Fireplace and police departments have been referred to as and the shopper was taken to the hospital, however DHCS was not notified as required.
• Questionable record-keeping, which may end in questionable insurance coverage billings. DHCS was recording an interview with two sufferers at the exact same time they have been marked as current and totally engaged in remedy periods. Their information contained detailed notes equivalent to “(Client 4) was early for group” and mentioned, “I am excited to be sober!” and “(Client 5) was present and punctual … highly engaged and willing to share,” and mentioned, “I need to worry about my sobriety over everything else.” DHCS mentioned the notes have been “inaccurate.”
Yang didn’t return requires remark. Younger declined to reply detailed questions however mentioned this by way of a spokesman: “I’m out here helping homeless people stay sober, find jobs and reintegrate into society without any help from charities or taxpayer subsidies. Can city and state officials say the same?”
Abused its discretion
In courtroom, Younger’s attorneys aggressively tried to counter the state’s assertions in an effort to maintain Elmo open till a listening to on the closure is held subsequent 12 months.
The DHCS in the end did approve Yang to offer medical providers, they mentioned in courtroom filings. Staff who allegedly falsified information have been let go. A compliance marketing consultant was introduced in to enhance operations. However DHCS didn’t weigh any of that, they argue.
State regulators additionally erred by citing Elmo for failing to conform not with state regulation or rules, however with the corporate’s personal inside insurance policies. “Simply put, there is no statute or regulation that elevates a program’s policies and procedures to the level of a licensing requirement,” Younger’s attorneys argue.
And if DHCS really believed sufferers confronted critical danger, why did it wait almost a 12 months to behave? The state exceeded its authority and abused its discretion, leading to a “senseless shutdown” that left some residents “back on the street” and a few staffers with out jobs, they argue.
After DHCS’s first go to final December, it issued three “Notices of Deficiencies.” This system director promptly supplied a “Corrective Action plan,” which was permitted by DHCS a couple of week later. Younger introduced on the compliance marketing consultant in August. However DHCS made no effort to find out if the deficiencies nonetheless existed, and didn’t return to the positioning till it shut issues down, attorneys argued.
“While I am informed that a few residents ended up in other detoxification/residential treatment facilities, others were not so fortunate and, I fear, will relapse into their addiction or worse,” Younger mentioned within the submitting.
Younger’s attorneys have mentioned insurer Aetna’s “outrageous allegations” are inflicting immense injury to enterprise and needs to be thrown out, and dismissed Delaware’s Rip-off Alert as “fiction” and “inflammatory speculation” so Aetna can keep away from paying thousands and thousands in excellent claims. In his newly filed declaration, Younger defended the the Aristocracy of his calling.
“My dedication to serving others began in early adulthood, when I enlisted in the U.S. military, from which I am now an honorably discharged veteran,” Younger mentioned within the declaration.
“I began my professional journey in hotel management, where I made it a priority to provide employment opportunities to formerly incarcerated individuals and the homeless. The tragic loss of my long-term girlfriend to an accidental overdose fueled my resolve to make an even greater impact and led me to transition to the substance abuse addiction industry.”
A listening to difficult Elmo’s license revocation is slated for Jan. 24. The request to carry DHCS’s order within the meantime was rejected by a decide.
“Elmo is unable to operate and yet must continue to pay rent and other overhead relating to the facility,” Younger mentioned. “As a result, Elmo is on the verge of having to be permanently closed. This is causing permanent damage to Elmo’s (and my) reputation in the substance use disorder treatment community, including with health care providers and referral sources.”
There’s no scarcity of unhealthy blood in opposition to Younger, nevertheless. He and his firms have been repeatedly dragged into courtroom for allegedly stiffing employees out of pay, stiffing landlords out of hire, and firing whistleblowers who balked on the unethical and/or unlawful issues they have been anticipated to do, based on courtroom paperwork.
Many individuals who’ve labored inside his operations have harrowing tales to inform. Others, nonetheless enrolled in therapy and employed by the community, sing its praises. Can all of them be proper?
Subsequent on this sequence: Contained in the operations.
Present Caption
1 of 4
Increase
Initially Revealed: November 25, 2024 at 6:05 AM PST
