Carrie Underwood to Step Down From ‘American Idol’ Amid New Controversies?

Studying Time: 3 minutes

Is Carrie Underwood about to stop American Idol?

It’s a query that followers have been asking all season.

And the difficulty has attracted extra consideration than ever amid shocking controversies surrounding Carrie’s first (and presumably final) season on the judges’ panel.

Carrie Underwood attends the 2024 Songwriters Corridor Of Fame Induction and Awards Gala at New York Marriott Marquis Resort on June 13, 2024 in New York Metropolis. (Picture by Pleasure Malone/Getty Pictures)

Carrie Underwood attracts surprising criticism

On Sunday evening, Jamal Roberts was topped the winner of the present’s twenty third season. And a few viewers felt that Carrie appeared lower than thrilled about the way in which the vote turned out.

“Damn I ain’t know Carrie Underwood was this racist,” one X consumer wrote this week.

“Lol dang, yall gone beat me up. she was racist to the winner of American Idol,” the consumer later elaborated, including:

“A black man gained and apparently she was being harsh on him all season, didn’t get up when he gained and didn’t hug or congratulate him however went to hug the loser.

Some commenters identified that Carrie did applaud for Roberts and even posted a pic with him on Instagram, whereas others linked the alleged snub to the truth that Underwood carried out on the inauguration of Donald Trump.

Carrie Underwood performs “America the Beautiful” throughout the inauguration of U.S. President Donald Trump on the U.S. Capitol Rotunda on January 20, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Picture by Julia Demaree Nikhinson – Pool/Getty Pictures)

Criticism for that call carried into the week’s different Idol-related controversy, as many followers criticized Carrie for singing alongside to a Whitney Houston tune on her Instagram web page.

Carrie receives criticism for Whitney Houston efficiency

As Parade journal factors out, Carrie crooned together with Houston’s hit “I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me),” and the video of her efficiency acquired a really combined response from followers.

“Girl, Whitney Houston would not like your MAGA ass,” popular culture account Mr. Pop, wrote in keeping with the outlet.

“Don’t dare sing Whitney,” one other consumer wrote. “Girl you leave Whitney song alon[e],” a 3rd chimed in.

Carrie Underwood attends Opry 100: A Reside Celebration at Grand Ole Opry on the Ryman Auditorium on March 19, 2025 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Picture by Jason Kempin/Getty Pictures for the Grand Ole Opry)

“She can’t beat Whitney’s vocals…sorry not sorry,” one consumer added, whereas one other echoed, “She’ll never be Whitney…lol.”

There have been additionally rumors that Carrie can be fired from Idol resulting from followers’ divided response to her first season. Nevertheless it doesn’t look like that would be the case.

“It’s early days still, but I love our panel,” showrunner Megan Michaels Wolflick lately advised TV Line.

“I think we’re in a good place. I’m excited for them to crown their first winner together as a threesome. They’re all passionate about the show,” she continued, including:

“We never share our hand before the end of the season, but it should be coming soon.”

So it seems like controversy or no controversy, the choice will finally be left as much as Carrie. We’re certain we’ll have an replace quickly!